Skip links

What Is Criminal Governance? A Social Psychological Perspective

The influence of criminal organisations can extend beyond other criminals to the communities in which they operate. They can regulate behaviour, settle disputes, implement norms, demand payment or control access to protection. These activities are part of the broader phenomenon of criminal governance, which refers to instances in which a criminal group engages in activities that shape other people’s lives. This raises the central questions of how organisations operating outside the law establish authority and how people respond to it.

Secret Power investigates these relationships from a social psychological perspective. It examines how people understand criminal authority, when they regard it as legitimate, and what drives accommodation, cooperation or opposition. This approach connects individual appraisals of criminal governance with shared values, social identities and perceived institutional conditions.

Organised crime and criminal governance

Organised crime refers to the groups and networks involved in criminal activity. Criminal governance concerns the relationships of power those actors establish.

A group may regulate an illegal market without controlling other aspects of a territory. However, when its rules extend to residents who are not members or participants in that market, its power becomes a concern for the wider community.

Political science, criminology, sociology and anthropology contribute to understanding these arrangements through research on institutions, illegal markets, local histories and everyday relationships. Social psychology adds questions about how people perceive criminal organisations’ power and respond to claims of authority Travaglino & Abrams, 2019.

How do criminal organisations exercise authority and social control?

Criminal groups can threaten violence, punish perceived violations and enforce their demands. They may also present their activities as protection or the maintenance of order.

Our research examines how people appraise such governance functions. For example, the development of the Legitimacy of Secret Power Scale considered evaluations of criminal groups’ roles in justice, protection, economic activity and community representation Travaglino et al., 2025.

Secret Power focuses on how criminal authority is viewed across different social settings. Relevant questions we pursue include whether a given group is seen as embodying valued qualities, how people understand their relationship with the community, and how they evaluate formal institutions’ responses.

In the L-SP validation research, favourable appraisals of criminal governance were associated with the endorsement of masculine honour, with greater legal cynicism and social dominance orientation, and with less favourable views of democracy and the police. Some of the patterns differed across the countries examined. For example, the association with masculine honour found in the UK, US and Italian samples was not significant in the Japanese sample. A psychological account therefore needs to consider these cultural and contextual differences Travaglino et al., 2025.

Intra-Cultural Appropriation Theory

Intra-Cultural Appropriation Theory (ICAT) proposes that criminal organisations can sustain power by appropriating values shared within a community and presenting themselves as the embodiment of such values. The theory focuses on how cultural meaning can serve relationships of domination by contributing to the justification of certain groups’ authority Travaglino & Abrams, 2019.

Research in Italy has examined masculine honour, beliefs about male reputation, self-reliance and the acceptability of using violence in response to threats or insults. Two studies using an implicit association task found that Italian participants associated male or masculine concepts more strongly with criminal organisations than with the state. In the second study, the association between masculine honour and legitimising attitudes was stronger among participants who also showed a stronger implicit association between masculinity and criminal organisations. This pattern highlights the importance of the perceived alignment between a group’s image and shared values Travaglino & Marini, 2025.

People’s social identities also play an important role. Studies conducted in Sicily found that the relationship between masculine honour and justification of connivance varied as a function of whether national or territorial identity was salient. An experiment that increased the salience of each identity provided evidence that the strength of the relationship can depend on which identity is brought to mind Mirisola et al., 2025.

The role of formal institutions

From a psychological perspective, the perception of institutions matters for how individuals respond to criminal organisations. In an eight-country survey, perceived state responsiveness was associated with stronger collective community efficacy, that is, the belief that people can work together to address local problems. Efficacy was, in turn, associated with stronger intentions to oppose organised crime. Notably, however, a second, smaller pathway linked responsiveness with lower perceived threat and weaker mobilisation intentions Moon et al., 2025.

How does Secret Power study these processes?

Secret Power is an international research programme led by Professor Giovanni Travaglino at Royal Holloway, University of London. It was awarded an ERC Starting Grant and is funded by UK Research and Innovation through the Frontier Research Guarantee.

The programme connects three areas of work:

  • Instruments and Foundations develops the concepts and measures needed to investigate appraisals of criminal governance across settings.
  • Society and Organised Crime examines relationships between individuals, communities and institutions using surveys and experimental approaches.
  • Socialising Legality follows adolescents over time to investigate the development of attitudes towards legal and extra-legal authority.

Different designs answer different questions. Surveys identify patterns of association; experiments can test causal effects; repeated observations can investigate change and temporal ordering. The publication summaries explain the designs of individual studies.

What does this perspective imply for societal responses?

The research examines the social relationships through which criminal power is perceived, sustained, and opposed.

For researchers and practitioners, useful questions concern whose authority is recognised, which values are invoked, what residents believe institutions can do, and whether collective opposition seems possible.

References

  • Travaglino, G. A., & Abrams, D. (2019). How criminal organisations exert secret power over communities: An intracultural appropriation theory of cultural values and norms. European Review of Social Psychology, 30(1), 74–122. DOI.
  • Travaglino, G. A., Mirisola, A., Moon, C., Burgmer, P., Imada, H., Giammusso, I., D’Ottone, S., Nawata, K., Ozeki, M., & Abrams, D. (2025). The psychology of criminal authority: Introducing the Legitimacy of Secret Power Scale. Group Processes & Intergroup Relations, 28(3), 477–503. DOI.
  • Travaglino, G. A., & Marini, M. (2025). The implicit association between masculinity and criminal organizations. Scientific Reports, 15, 19866. DOI.
  • Mirisola, A., Travaglino, G. A., & Giammusso, I. (2025). National identification weakens, and territorial identification strengthens, the relationship between masculine honor values and the justification of practices of connivance with the mafia. Political Psychology, 46(5), 965–987. DOI.
  • Moon, C., Travaglino, G. A., Mirisola, A., Burgmer, P., D’Ottone, S., Giammusso, I., Imada, H., Nawata, K., & Ozeki, M. (2025). State responsiveness, collective efficacy and threat perception: Catalyst and complacency effects in opposition to crime across eight countries. British Journal of Social Psychology, 64(1), e12832. DOI.
  • Travaglino, G. A., Burgmer, P., & Mirisola, A. (2024). Alternative systems: The interplay between criminal groups’ influence and political trust on civic honesty in the global context. Social Psychological and Personality Science, 15(4), 439–449. DOI.
This website uses cookies to improve your web experience.